REVIEW: “If Carthay Circle & Brown Derby Had a Baby on the Sea” – Dining at 1923 Aboard the Disney Wish

The Disney Wish, the newest ship in the Disney Cruise Line fleet, has several unique offerings. We dined at 1923, one of the rotational dinner restaurants, and tried everything on the menu.


DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 43 scaled

First off, the restaurant is actually separated into two dining rooms, the Walt Disney and the Roy Disney. Make sure to check your Navigator app to see which one you are dining at.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 5 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 7 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 18 scaled

The space is meant to evoke golden age Hollywood dining, such as Musso & Frank or a visit to the Frolic Room.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 1 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 21 scaled

Throughout, sketches and concept art along with maquettes used for producing some of Disney’s most iconic animated features are displayed.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 8 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 9 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 11 1 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 12 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 24 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 26 scaled

“Beauty and the Beast” in particular is prominently represented.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 4 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 20 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 22 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 15 scaled

Tableware is largely copper and white-colored. Everything from plates to salt and pepper shakers bears the 1923 logo.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 29 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 30 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 31 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 32 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 33 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 34 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 35 scaled

Also represented are classic films like “Peter Pan” and “Bambi.”

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 36 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 37 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 38 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 39 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 40 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 41 scaled

Even oft-forgotten films like “The Sword in the Stone” see representation here.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 42 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 44 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 45 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 46 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 47 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 48 scaled

“Moana” and “Frozen” have a home here too.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 49 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 50 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 51 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 52 scaled

The restaurant celebrates 100 years of Disney animation, from the founding of the Walt Disney Company in 1923, all the way up to today. The two separate 1923 dining rooms, “Walt Disney” and “Roy Disney”, travel through time starting from the back of the restaurant, and then greet diners upon entry with displays representing more recent films.

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 53 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 54 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 55 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 56 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 57 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 58 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 59 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 60 scaled

And of course we can’t forget “Pinocchio,” “Alice in Wonderland,” and “Sleeping Beauty.”

DCL Disney Wish 1923 interior 61 scaled

The displays range from maquettes to art prints, to fun scene-dissecting pieces, and more. While some “props” are simply merchandise pieces from the past, there are some custom-made items on display, including a sami drum for the Northuldra people in Frozen two that was handmade by a. couple in Finland, as well as the Fijian ship model representing Moana that is made by a Hawaiian artist.

1923 Menu

DCL Disney Wish 1923 dinner menu 2 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 dinner menu 1 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 dinner menu 5 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 dinner menu 4 scaled

The menu features items with nods to many LA-area landmarks and locations important to Walt and Roy:

  • Alameda – Alameda Avenue was once home to the Walt Disney Studios
  • Hyperion – The Disney brothers moved their Studio from the original Kingswell Avenue location to 2719 Hyperion in Los Angeles in January 1926, and named it The Walt Disney Studio
  • Kingswell – Site of the first Disney Studio in Hollywood.
  • Riverside – The current Disney studio resides along Riverside Drive.
  • Buena Vista – Located in Burbank, California, where the Walt Disney Studios are located (500 South Buena Vista Street.  It was from the name of Buena Vista Street that Disney chose the name for its distribution company.
  • Los Feliz – In 1932 Walt and Lillian had their Los Feliz home built at 4053 Woking Way, Los Angeles, CA. 
  • Ink & Paint – This is an important department at the studio, in fact this is where Lillian was working when she met Walt.
  • Atwater – Atwater Village is a district of Los Angeles, which was frequented by Walt and his animators in the early days of the Disney Studio. This hip area is located just across the Glendale-Hyperion Bridge from the studio.
  • Hollywood Hills – The Carolwood Estate once owned by Walt Disney was located at Holmby Hills, Los Angeles in the Hollywood Hills.
  • Burbank – Walt Disney used the earnings from the successful release of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs to finance the construction of the Burbank studio.

Bread Service

Fig and Olive Bread with Honey Butter Dip

DCL Disney Wish 1923 22 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 24 scaled

The fig and olive bread is quite good, but they’re also mixed in with some of the standard rolls that are served with meal services aboard. The honey butter dip makes anything good, adding a sweetness and creaminess to every bite.


Alameda Porcini Spiced Ahi Tuna

Pickled Lotus Root, Oyster Mushroom, Black Sesame Brittle, Wasabi, and Yuzu Mayonnaise

DCL Disney Wish 1923 37 scaled

It’s not the best tuna we’ve had, but it does the job for those looking to eat a little lighter. The yuzu mayonnaise and wasabi will elevate each bite, but some of the other parts of the dish may have not been as fresh as they could be,

Hyperion Four-cheese Tri-color Tortelloni

Meyer Lemon, Artichoke, Sun-dried Tomato, Baby Spinach

DCL Disney Wish 1923 58 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 59 scaled

We were worried about the tortellini by the look of it, but it was honestly quite good. They’re a little doughy, on the al dente side, but that’s probably how they are best served. Each one is plump and filled with rich cheese. The portion is small, so be forewarned that you may want to order more than one for the table. We certainly regret not doing so.

Burrata Mozzarella Cheese & Prosciutto di Parma

Crisp Cranberry and Sunflower Seed Phyllo, Charred Blood Orange

Honestly, we’ve never been blown away with the food on Disney Cruise Line outside of some experiences at Remy, Palo, and the like, so we were surprised by just how acceptable some of the dishes were at 1923 (I know that isn’t exactly high praise), especially after the cataclysmically bad meal we had at Worlds of Marvel. The burrata was more than adequate, tasting moist and fresh, nicely accompanied by the salty prosciutto. I believe this will please those in the mood for it.

Kingswell Duck Confit Pastilla

Dates, Apricot, Ginger, Red Pepper, Saffron, Black Raspberry Jam

DCL Disney Wish 1923 46 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 44 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 57 scaled

The quality of the duck was not top-shelf here, but it was an OK dish. The intense sweetness of the apricot and the black raspberry jam made the dish somewhat enjoyable.


Fennel, Bartlett Pear, and Tatsoi Salad

Manchego Cheese, Walnuts, Sherry Dressing

The pear is sweet, the fennel is bitter, and the entire combination is quite refreshing. The Manchego and the walnuts elevated the dish, making for a winning salad that is worth trying.

Split Napa Baby Romaine Lettuce

Caesar Dressing, Heirloom Grape Tomatoes, Parmigiano-Reggiano, Ciabatta Garlic Croutons

DCL Disney Wish 1923 90

A standard salad that is along the lines of a Caesar salad for those looking for it.

From the Kettle

DCL Disney Wish 1923 80

Pulled Guinea Hen Corn Chowder

Yukon Gold Potato, Cilantro, Smoked Bacon

DCL Disney Wish 1923 82

We don’t know how much flavor the pulled guinea hen meat adds to this, but without it, you have a perfectly fine corn chowder. It’s thick and salty, filled with chunks of corn.

Roasted Roma Tomato Soup

Sourdough Purple Basil Crostini

DCL Disney Wish 1923 83

Again, here’s another dish that won’t change your life, but that we think you’ll enjoy. It’s a vegan option as well, but that doesn’t mean everyone can’t enjoy this well-seasoned tomato soup that is just thick enough in consistency. The sourdough crostini soaked in the soup was enjoyable as well.


Tortiglioni Pasta

Prosecco Cream, Pancetta, Shallots, Cremini Mushrooms, Lemon Thyme

A rather mediocre pasta dish that is very one-note in its cream flavor. It is probably over-salted and slightly overcooked as well.

Seared Verlasso Salmon Filet

Californian Wild Honey Parsnip Purée, Orange Fennel Essence, Sauteéd Black Garlic Rapini

A perfectly serviceable piece of salmon. It wasn’t too dry, but it also wasn’t the most tender or moist piece. The two pieces of rapini (which are nicely prepared with an oily coating and offer a pleasant crunch in each bite) are the only real side that comes with this, so be forewarned, it may not be the most filling entree on the menu.

Italian Flat Parsley and Rosemary-crusted Rack of Lamb

Dauphinoise Potato, Roasted Petite Turnip, Carrot and Zucchini, Zinfandel Rosemary Sauce

DCL Disney Wish 1923 92

This was the highlight of the meal for us. The lamb was as tender, juicy, and bursting with flavor as it could be. It is heavily seasoned, but it absolutely works, especially offset by the thick and rich zinfandel rosemary sauce.

1923 Peppered Filet Mignon

Buttered Long Green Beans, Smoked Bacon, Crushed Fingerling Potato Hash, Pink Pepper Café Au Lait

There are some rather disappointing cuts of beef on board, this might be the best of the bunch though. It was cooked correctly to medium inside, had a nice, slight char on the exterior, and was properly seasoned. The accompaniment left something to be desired as the bacon was undercooked and the potato hash was somewhat flavorless. The green beans were good at least.

Lighter Notes

Los Feliz Lobster Salad

Baby Bibb, Endive Lettuce, Avocado, Jicama, Celery, Purple Potato, Tostones, Black Beans, Grape Tomatoes, Cilantro, Lime

We were really surprised by the amount of lobster and avocado on top of this, making it not quite as light of an option as you might expect. It’s a really nice mix of vegetables with the light, yet richly flavored Bibb lettuce, in total creating possibly the best salad option on the entire ship.


DCL Disney Wish 1923 dessert menu 2 1 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 dessert menu 3 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 dessert menu 1 scaled

Churros Calientes

Sugar Spice Churros, Dulce de Leche

DCL Disney Wish 1923 138

These were a big disappointment. They did not come out hot and the dulce de leche sauce was a little too thick and overpowered the intended texture and flavor of each bite of churro. We know they sound good, but they weren’t, so trust us and skip them.

Flourless Orange Almond Cake

Guava Gel, Lychee Yogurt Crème

DCL Disney Wish 1923 117

The dish would probably benefit from a little more of the yogurt creme as it’s a drier cake. The guava gel is sweet enough to offset most of it, but you’ll want to distribute that white, sweet creme as much as possible if you order this.

Atwater Fuji Apple Cheesecake

Sweet Dough Shell, Caramelized Apples, Cinnamon Cheesecake, Rolled Oat Crumble

DCL Disney Wish 1923 119 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 143 scaled

Here comes the “Disney Flavor Lab Special”. Since Pandora opened in 2017, we can’t even count the amount of these “mousse wheel” desserts we’ve had at Walt Disney World and beyond. That being said, this is actually one of the better entries. The apple crumble below is perhaps dry on its own, but when combined with the moist cheesecake covered in caramel, it is a memorable and delicious end to a meal.

Hollywood Hills Hot Chocolate Fudge Sundae

Vanilla Ice Cream, Fudge Brownie Bites, fresh Whipped Cream, Glazed Cherry

Every restaurant in the dining rotation offers some sort of ice cream sundae, and this one feels the most in-theme and is the most satisfying. It’s just vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, brownies and whipped cream, but sometimes that is all you want after a good meal. The brownie bits are soft and moist and the hot fudge is properly hot, making for a solid option. There’s something about the look and color of this dessert matched against the setting that just feels right, so if you want to order one just for a cute picture, we totally understand.

Signature Dessert: Burbank Blueberry-Lemon Bavarian Cream

Ecuador Vanilla Bean, Lemon Rocks, Dried Raspberry Meringue

DCL Disney Wish 1923 113 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 112 scaled
DCL Disney Wish 1923 142 scaled

The cream ended top being the primary flavor here, with he blueberry and lemon being way too masked in every bite. While the presentation is pretty, it’s just not worth ordering.

Coconut Tapioca Pudding (No Sugar Added)

Strawberry-lime Salsa, Matcha Crumble

For a no-sugar-added dessert, this was very popular at our table. The base heft of the coconut pudding is filling, and that creaminess perfectly pairs with the strawberry and lime flavors above and the match crumble. I would order this again.


The Buena Vista Boulevardier – $12

Woodford Chocolate Rye, Campari, Lillet Rouge

DCL 1923Cocktails 2
DCL 1923Cocktails 3

The Boulevardier feels like the proper cocktail to drink in this venue, maybe because of the giant logo chocolate piece on top though. Woodford is our preferred rye more often than not, and the Lillet Rouge is a nice stand in for what is typically Campari.

The Riverside Old Fashioned – $12

Old Forester 1920, Bourbon Barrel Maple

DCL 1923Cocktails 1

There are a lot of Old Fashioned on this ship, and this isn’t one of the more memorable beyond the candied bacon. I’d save your money and take it to Hook’s Barbery or to The Rose (where Jennifer and a team of very experienced Disney Cruise Line bartenders can make you an off-menu one).

The Hyperion Highball – $10

Glenmorangie Nectar D’Or, Ginger Beer

DCL 1923Cocktails 5

The Glenmorangie Nectar D’Or, is typically described as follows:

“Lemonade, icing sugar, vanilla, nougat, and maple on the nose. Progressively sweeter. Rich and seet on the palate, notably fruity, with spicy orange and brittle toffee. Medium length finish, with milk chocolate-coated ginger and lingering toffee.”

That mixed with ginger beer did not make for a cocktail we would order again, but those with a different taste in cocktails may disagree.

Lillet Experience – $18

Lillet Blanc, Lillet Rosé, Lillet Rogue

Walk back in time and discover the classic flavors of the French aperitif, all paired to some exciting bites.

DCL 1923Cocktails 4

This may be worth ordering just because you’ll probably never forget it. It’s a nice way for someone to try these wines for the first time, paired with fun and easily recognizable snack pairings (M&M’s, nuts, etc). It’s a charming little experience that is well-priced, shareable, and should be enjoyed at this venue. Here’s a little more info about the wines:

French aromatized aperitif wine made with a blend of Bordeaux grapes and fortified with a blend of citrus liqueurs. It is a blend of 85% Bordeaux region wines (Semillon for the Blanc and for the Rosé, Merlot for the Rouge) and 15% macerated liqueurs, mostly citrus liqueurs (peels of sweet oranges from Spain and Morocco and peels of bitter green oranges from Haiti).

• Lillet Rouge (1962–present): A red-wine-based liqueur first suggested by the American wine merchant and importer Michael Dreyfus, one of the first to import Lillet into the US

• Lillet Blanc (1986–present): A sweeter variant of the white-wine-based version with reduced quinine flavoring. It replaced Kina Lillet.

• Lillet Rosé (2011–present): A rosé-wine-based liqueur.

Lillet is an aperitif wine, intended to be served well chilled at 6–8 °C (43–46 °F). In France, Lillet is usually served on ice with a slice of orange, or a lemon or lime peel. In other countries, especially in the US and UK, it is more often used as a cocktail ingredient.


1923 is a perfectly enjoyable restaurant on the Disney Wish. Not offering a show is a nice change of pace, and honestly a necessary diversion from the other venues, giving family and friends a chance to actually sit at a meal and talk to each other. At times, the cuisine reminds us of Carthay Circle Restaurant and Hollywood Brown Derby, which is fitting given the interior echoes both at times as well, but when you serving California cuisine of a certain quality, you are bound to be similar to those theme park restaurants. It probably also draws comparisons since it literally plays the same background music loop as the Disney California Adventure restaurant icon restaurant as well.

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.